The most important thing is that the query returning the list used for default values has the exact same items listed in the same order as what is being used to populate the selection list. If you have the same dataset hooked up for both then that should be a no brainer. I confirmed that this works using SSRS 2005 service pack 2. If you are not on the latest service pack or an earlier version of SSRS then you may be out of luck as there's nothing else that I can suggest...sorry.